火狐体育

菜单导航

【学习园地】扎伤非法讨债的,算正当防卫吗?

作者: 张馨予 发布时间: 2020年09月27日 08:54:47

  “zheigeanjianduiwomendechudonghenda,conggenbenshanggaibianleguoqu‘sheisishangsheiyouli’desiwei。”riqian,zailingbaoshijunxianjianchayuanjuxingde“anshuozhengdangfangwei”songfajinnongcunhuodongxianchang,gaixianxinzhenzhenpaichusuominjingqinchaoduijizheshuo。

  双方对打斗情况各执一词

  2019nian2yue16ri,huangdongxu(huaming)zaijunxianxinzhenzhenmoucunzhaozhaiwurenjiasikai(huaming)taozhaishi,beijiasikaideerzijiazhenggang(huaming)zhachengqingshang。

  dangtianxiawu,shoushangdehuangdongxuzijijiachegandaoxinzhenzhenweishengyuanduishangkoujinxingjinjichuli,houzhuanzhijunxianrenminyiyuanzhuyuanjieshoushoushuzhiliao。houjingjianding,huangdongxudesunshangchengdushuyuqingshangyiji。

  2019nian4yue26ri,junxiangonganjuduigaianlianzhencha。5yue12ri,fanzuixianyirenjiazhenggangtouanzishou,houbeixingshijuliu。5yue17ri,junxiangonganjuyijiazhenggangshexianguyishanghaizuixiangjunxianjianchayuantiqingpizhundaibu。

  “gonganjiguanjianggaiantiqingpizhundaibudeyijujiushihuangdongxudeshangqingjianding。”zhubangaiandejunxianjianchayuandiyijianchabuzhurenchenshuhengjieshao,gaiyuanfayizaijinxingwenzhengshenchashifaxian,yuanfayijiandingjingenjuhuangdongxusuoshoudaoshangdedaokouzhangduleijijiangqipingdingweiqingshang,erweipingjiaqitashangqing,xuyaozhongxinjianding;zaizhe,shuangfangduidadouqingkuanggezhiyici,xuyaoduixijiejinxingxunwenhexunwen。

  jianyuci,gaiyuanjiangciantuihuibuchongzhencha。

  仔细审查发现隐情

  退回补充侦查期间,贾正刚的律师向检察机关反映, 公安机关在处理双方矛盾时,曾对黄东旭下达行政处罚决定书,该决定书认定黄东旭实施了非法侵入他人住宅、殴打他人、损坏财物的行为,且其违法行为“严重”。

  “ruguoshizheiyang,neijiazhenggangdexingweishifougouchengzhengdangfangwei?”chenshuhengyouleyihuo。juci,tayaoqiugonganjiguanjianggaixingzhengchufajuedingshuyibingfujuanyisong。

  buchajieguoxianshi,gonganjiguanzaiduijiazhenggangtiqingdaibuhou,yu6yue15riduihuangdongxuzuochule“hebingzhixingxingzhengjuliu20ri,fakuan500yuan”dechufajueding。juci,chenshuhengrenweijiazhenggangdexingweikenenggouchengzhengdangfangwei。taxianggaiyuanjianchazhangliubozuolexiangxihuibao,yededaolemingquezhichi。

  

【学习园地】扎伤非法讨债的,算正当防卫吗?


  bananjianchaguandaoanfaxianchangxiangzhiqingrenxunwenheduianqing。

  weilejinyibuchaqingzhenxiang,chenshuhengliangcidaoanfaxianchangjinxingshididiaocha,haiyuanleanfashideqingjing。

  案发当天,黄东旭开车来到贾正刚家门口,下车后一边问坐在门口的老太太(贾思凯母亲),“贾思凯在不在家?”一边径直往里闯。老太太起身阻拦,黄东旭一把将其推翻在地,后又顺手捡起一根一米多长的木棍,一边推开大门高喊“有人没”,一边冲到堂屋门口,将堂屋门上的玻璃砸烂,后进屋找人。客厅和第一个房间都没人,当他推开第二个房门时,贾正刚手持水果刀冲了出来。二人打斗时,黄东旭多处被水果刀刺中。其间,贾正刚的妻子抱着两个被吓哭的孩子跑出堂屋报了案。

  yuanlai,jiasikaiyu2019nian9yuexianghuangdongxudemuqinjiekuan7wanyuan,bingyuedinglelixi。2019nian,fayuanpanjuejiasikaichanghaihuangdongxubenxiheji8.2wanyuan。houhuangdongxuxiangfayuanshenqingqiangzhizhixing,danjiasikaitaobizhixing,lijiaduoleqilai。qiafengchunjie,huangdongxuxiangzhejiasikaikenengzaijia,jiujuedingquzhuangzhuangyunqi。“yiqianhaojicidoushitamuqinzulanburangjinjia。”yinci,huangdongxuyikandaozuozaimenkoudejiamu,qijiubudayichulai,yushibianfashengleqianwensuoshuyimu。

  2019年12月,明确了沉睡多年的正当防卫法律规定正确适用问题,传达了“法不能向不法让步”的鲜明司法导向。随即,浚县检察院逐级向鹤壁市检察院、灵宝市检察院作了汇报。两级检察院对该案认定为正当防卫没有异议。2019年12月,浚县检察院依法认定贾正刚的行为属于正当防卫,不负刑事责任。

  双方都接受的结果

  “zaigonganjiguanshiguyishanghai,daojianchayuanzajiuchenglezhengdangfangwei?sheilaiweihuwodehefaquanyini?”jinnian1yue,huangdongxujiujunxianjianchayuandebuqisujuedingxianghebishijianchayuantichushensu。

  “hefaquanyiyaoyonghefatujingquweihu……”zaiciqijian,jianchaguanduociweiqijiangjiexiangguanfalvguiding,bingtongguozhidaoxinganliyuqixingweijinxingbijiaoduizhao,duiqijinxingshifashuoli。ciwai,junxianjianchayuanjiuhuangdongxuminshizhixinganjianqingkuangyufayuanduocijinxinggoutong,bingtongguozhixingjianduchengxu,jianyifayuanjiadazhixinglidu。

  houfayuanjingduibeizhixingrenjiasikaidecaichanjinxingchaxun,faxianqizaipanjueshengxiaohouyou3wanyuyuandezijinwanglai,qiezaiwaidagongyueshouru3000yuyuan,haizaiqijiazhongfaxianlianggekeyidonglengku。danjiasikairengbuyuanchanghaihuangdongxuzhaiwu:suibeifayuansifajuliuliangci,rengbulvxingpanjueyiwu。2019nian10yue19ri,liuboliexijunxianfayuanshenweihui,jianyijianggaianyisonggonganjulianzhencha。jinnian6yue23ri,jinggaiyuanyifatiqigongsu,jiasikaibeifayuanyijubuzhixingpanjuezuipanchuyouqituxingyinianlingsangeyue。

热门标签